Reviews for A Knock On The Door
Lola Weasley | 2005.09.05 - 02:31PM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
Awesome!!!!
Author's Response: Thanks. Lol. |
TRE | 2005.09.05 - 02:10PM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
That was an excellent bit of fiction!
Author's Response: Thanks so much. Glad you enjoyed it. Lol. |
joannie | 2005.09.05 - 01:39PM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
Love it - as far as I read. I had to quit reading when Lily's name entered the scene. Seems we think alike and I don't want to influence my storyline. I'll wait till mine is fleshed out more and come back to this one.
Author's Response: Oh, now I'm intrigued. Shall look forward to hearing from you again, soon. Lol. |
BDP | 2005.09.05 - 01:34PM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
i really enjoyed it.... i dont like to think of James like the way you have portrayed him... but it was a very interesting view of things.... which could be belived
Author's Response: It would surprise me if James turns out to be evil, but you have to admit, from the Pensive scene he DID behave quite badly, and it seemed he and Sirius were always in trouble. Thanks for your review, I'm glad you enjoyed the story. Lol. |
swooning | 2005.09.05 - 11:32AM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
Here's an amendment to my first review, added after reading some of the others... My vote is: do NOT write a sequel. Not because it isn't good enough, because it certainly IS good enough. But because I think what you've written stands beautifully on its own as a tiny little slice of one possible future. A future that JKR will never write, of course, but an extremely plausible future nevertheless. It's a perfectly wrought miniature... and that's okay.
Author's Response: Thanks. Wouldn't it be a shock if JKR DID write a connection between Hermione and Snape? Not romantically, of course, but if they ended up working together, or something. Thanks for your support about it being a one-shot. Lol. |
nocturnus | 2005.09.05 - 11:21AM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
I definitely love this fic and pretend to follow it. Please remember to announce at wiktt your updates.
Author's Response: No updates, I'm afraid. It's a one-shot. But yes, I could register it at WIKTT, couldn't I? Thanks for reading. Lol. |
swooning | 2005.09.05 - 11:15AM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
That was just brilliant on many, many levels. Well done.
Author's Response: Thanks so much. Glad you enjoyed it. Lol. |
Snapesforte | 2005.09.05 - 10:40AM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
I enjoyed this very much - the ongoing tension was thrilling, as was the fine attention to canon. And I think it's a perfect ending. Well done! Definitely a 10.
Author's Response: Thanks very much, Snapesforte. Your review has made me very happy. Lol. |
[Previous] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 [Next]
|