Reviews for A Knock On The Door
feather | 2005.09.16 - 09:19PM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
sorry but my imagination just isn't that good. you need to help me out...
Author's Response: Oh come on! Whoever it is, it's not good news, because the best thing to have happened was for Hermione to return to Hogwarts and for Severus to get the hell out of there, but they were too late. Does this help? Lol. |
loves23rules | 2005.09.16 - 05:18PM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
Very well written and a really plausible explanation. Remember the lines fore-shadowing the last book in the third film? Lily Evans was a person who could see beauty were others failed to notice it....
Author's Response: Whatever the real truth is, I'm sure Snape did not kill Albus out of hate. There was a reason, and it was a good reason. Yes, that description of Lily will come in to play in the last book, I think. Thanks for your review. Lol. |
Sooz | 2005.09.15 - 07:57AM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
Fantastic version of what may be happening after HBP. Really well thought out and a perfect cliffie ending. Sometimes that is the only ending. Thanks so much!
Author's Response: What a lovely review. Thank YOU so much. Glad you enjoyed it. Lol. |
SevsAngel | 2005.09.14 - 06:54AM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
Oh that's just wong....and yet so right...
I love your idea of the potion being a Horcrux, and Dumbledore swallowing it, thereby carrying a part of Voldemort with him. Brilliant idea there. Makes me wish I had thought of it.
Lovely smut and just the right amount of plot to really get ones blood pumping. Bravo!
Casandra
Author's Response: Thank you. I hope I'm right about the potion being the Horcrux - it does bode well for Snape if it was. Glad to have hightened the cardio rate! Thanks for your review. Lol. |
Atropos4 | 2005.09.14 - 12:29AM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
oooh wait....What Hermione was looking for in the bookshelves. Was it the locket? If it was completely ignore my last comment because then it all makes sense.. *giggles
Author's Response: No, it wasn't the locket. I think most people now think the locket is the one at Grimmauld Place, that couldn't be opened. Hermione was looking for a memory that Albus would have stored, which would let people know what Severus had done and why - and hopefully keep him from Azkaban. Lol. |
Atropos4 | 2005.09.14 - 12:26AM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
hmm well I like your theories. The only thing I have trouble believing is the potion Dumbledore drank made him a horcrux. R.A.B has already taken the locket therefore drank the potion and is dead. *shrugs I guess it could still work but seems less likely.
I loved the story though. That ending!! Too bad there isn't more. ^_^
Author's Response: I have to admit I haven't worked out entirely how it all works with the locket and RAB, but it looked so much to me like Albus drank the part-soul, and all that talk as to whether it could reside in a living being... I figured the two children Tom Riddle took into the cave might be a clue that he had committed a double murder in the cave and therefore there were two part-souls there. The liquid becoming the Horcrux was after, if not because of, RAB. As I say, I haven't thought that bit through, but still thinking Albus drank the soul. Anyhow, thank you for reviewing. I'm glad you liked the ending. Lol. |
wizard girl | 2005.09.13 - 05:34AM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
omg that has to be the absolute best ending ever. u left me with my mouth hanging open. wow. i've read more than my share of fanfics, and out of allll of them, i have to say that this is the best cliff-hanger ever. i was awed completely. this is like a 15/10.
Author's Response: I've never, ever got 15/10 before. Thanks so much. Really glad you enjoyed it. Thank you for being one of the few who liked the way it ended, and for leaving a lovely review. Lol. |
Audrey Johnson | 2005.09.12 - 10:13PM | 1: A Knock On The Door | Signed |
GAAH. heart attack. nicely done, by the way.
Author's Response: Hehehe. Thanks. Lol. |
[Previous] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 [Next]
|