Reviews for Birthday Wishes
| snapefan1983 | 2017.09.03 - 07:54PM | 4: Chapter Four | Signed |
| does he love her too is that why he is happy she loves him and that his wish came true that she loves him and he loves her??? He closed his eyes. As he took a deep breath he knew it didn’t matter if he blew out all the candles or not. For even though he knew nothing could come of it while she was still his student, he still smiled inwardly at one thought.
His wish had already come true.
She loved him. |
| snapefan1983 | 2017.09.03 - 07:51PM | 4: Chapter Four | Signed |
| so confused by this: However, for a change Snape was glad to have a diversion. Anything to keep him from thinking about what had just happened.
He walked into the Great Hall expecting to find something amiss. Instead, he was greeted with many roars of “Happy Birthday!”
The Great Hall was decorated for a party. Thousands of balloons floated in the air. Just as many candles floated along side them. There was a continuous sound of popping, as the balloons would float too close to the candles and pop. Then immediately another balloon would take its place. The effect was a kind of popping song.
Everyone seemed to be there in the Great Hall for his birthday.
He made his way to the front of the room where the headmaster stood ready to greet him.
“Happy Birthday, Severus,” he said warmly.
“Thank you, Headmaster,” he responded forgetting to contradict him about his birthday.
There was a large cake |
| snapefan1983 | 2017.09.03 - 07:51PM | 4: Chapter Four | Signed |
| why did she do that?? if she is anume to the potion?? “Happy Birthday, Professor.” She smiled at him as she walked in to serve her undeserved detention.
“Miss Granger, it is not my birthday.”
She seemed confused at his statement.
“Are you sure, professor?”
Instead of answering her question, he asked a question of his own.
“Have you ever known when my birthday was, Miss Granger?”
She thought about this. She actually had never known before when his birthday was. Not because she wasn’t interested but because he was a very private person. This further confused her.
“It seems, Miss Granger,” he continued, “that you are not immune to the effects of this potion after all.”
To his surprise, she blushed.
“Well, since it is somewhat of a festive occasion, why don’t we have a drink.” He retrieved two glasses with pumpkin juice in them. |
| snapefan1983 | 2017.09.03 - 07:45PM | 4: Chapter Four | Signed |
| why did she do that?? if she is anume to the potion?? “Happy Birthday, Professor.” She smiled at him as she walked in to serve her undeserved detention.
“Miss Granger, it is not my birthday.”
She seemed confused at his statement.
“Are you sure, professor?”
Instead of answering her question, he asked a question of his own.
“Have you ever known when my birthday was, Miss Granger?”
She thought about this. She actually had never known before when his birthday was. Not because she wasn’t interested but because he was a very private person. This further confused her.
“It seems, Miss Granger,” he continued, “that you are not immune to the effects of this potion after all.”
To his surprise, she blushed.
“Well, since it is somewhat of a festive occasion, why don’t we have a drink.” He retrieved two glasses with pumpkin juice in them. |
| snapefan1983 | 2017.09.03 - 07:40PM | 4: Chapter Four | Signed |
| and the headmaster too who is male is not meant to be afected by the potion AND HERMIONE wishing him a happy birthday and is not meant to be affetced by the potion because she already loves him This potion will affect all those who are of the opposite sex of the drinker. There are no exceptions to this.
If a person seems to not be affected, it is not due to any mistake in the potion. Rather it is an indication
that the person who is seemingly unaffected is actually already in love with the drinker of the potion. This person would have been so successful in previously hiding his or her feelings that he or she would have no trouble in continuing in this manner.
and since the headmaster is male and severus is male the potion should not be affecting the headmaster a male but only female lavender etc but NOT HERMIONE who is female but she is not beause she loves him already !!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
| snapefan1983 | 2017.09.03 - 07:36PM | 4: Chapter Four | Signed |
i thought the potion only affected the opposite sex?? so why is Hagrid who was not before affected by the potion saying happy birthday to him as if he is affected by it
“Happy Birthday, Professor Snape,” Hagrid said happily.
Author's Response: I wrote this 13 years ago but I think my thought at the time was that everyone heard those affected by the potion saying Happy Birthday and it spread all around the school that it was Snape's b-day. Sorry it was confusing. |
| Eucalyptus | 2016.08.17 - 12:50PM | 3: Chapter Three | Signed |
| This is the first time reading a SS/HG fic where I have laughed out loud. Mercy, that was hysterical. |
| marisamarinee | 2015.02.17 - 02:43AM | 5: Epilogue | Signed |
| hmm starting on the sequel now |
[Previous] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 [Next]
|