Reviews for Time Will Follow
bubbles28 | 2018.05.06 - 02:29AM | 12: Farewell to Billy | Signed |
Overall I like it, fairly straightforward, although I feel like we were building up to Billy being a potential threat and that didn't happen. I also kind of felt like their emotional reveal happened pretty quickly, and this Snape isn't very angsty, or conflicted. I suppose because his memories are gone?They seemed so ready to fall in love. I'm not sure I'm prepared to believe it given how quickly it happened, but on the other hand sometimes it can just happen swiftly and easily. Hermione too, she was career oriented but I guess slightly at loose ends/a loss in her life, and she seems fairly content with living out an alternative life...I guess because she gets two runs at the same three years? She's not technically missing out, just having an alternative adventure.
Author's Response: Thanks, I appreciate your thoughts! |
loreen77 | 2018.03.14 - 05:01AM | 12: Farewell to Billy | Signed |
For me the death of the spiders ends up feeling cruel. Unless the potion has serious life saving properties, it feels wrong for so many spiders to be sacrificed for so little venom. What potion will it be used in?. But potions throughout the canon books often felt similarly cruel. So many creatures seemed to be sacrificed for basic potions. You were true to canon and it was an exciting chapter. It is not your fault that this is one area of the books that never sat well with me.
Author's Response: Thanks for your reviews! |
loreen77 | 2018.03.11 - 10:43AM | 12: Farewell to Billy | Signed |
For me the death of the spiders ends up feeling cruel. Unless the potion has serious life saving properties, it feels wrong for so many spiders to be sacrificed for so little venom. What potion will it be used in?. But potions throughout the canon books often felt similarly cruel. So many creatures seemed to be sacrificed for basic potions. You were true to canon and it was an exciting chapter. It is not your fault that this is one area of the books that never sat well with me.
Author's Response: Yes, there is much casual cruelty built into canon HP |
|