Reviews for Getting the Best of the Gloomilows
|DarkenCoul||2018.06.14 - 11:10PM||1: The Incident in the Hallway||Signed |
|This opening chapter was wonderful, I love the situation you created to put him in front of her again for him to take real notice of her state of mind. Much better than if she had done something intentional to get his attention. You have a real uncanny knack to get into the mind of Severus and the way he was portrayed, both in books and in the wonderful acting of the very much missed Alan Rickman. His puzzlement and consternation with his feelings towards Hermione is downright endearing from the outsiders perspective. I love stories like these that aim to get inside the characters and reveal their thought processes instead of being nothing but action action action. It makes for a much more layered character and makes the why behind their actions much more understandable and relatable. Also, loved the closing line, he's definitely feeling a bit entangled! <3|
Author's Response: I absolutely love with how much detail you respond to each and every chapter! I realize that it take a lot of time and effort to put your thought into words and I very much appreciate the feedback! Thank you!!!
|StebadieSnape||2018.05.02 - 01:19AM||1: The Incident in the Hallway||Signed |
|This is such a great story. I can't wait to see where this will go. I like that you're showing us more seduction of the mind while she's still a student. I think Severus really would be trying to resist and be honorable. |
Author's Response: Don't worry, he's deeply honorable! This story is all about intimacy of the mind. :) At least until graduation...
|Eucalyptus||2017.11.08 - 08:24PM||1: The Incident in the Hallway||Signed |
|Canít wait for more! |
Author's Response: Oh no! I just noted that the new chapter I posted two weeks ago doesn't turn up in my account! I've been wondering why it took the admins so long to approve it! Something must have gone wrong while saving it! :( I'll have to to it again tomorrow...
|silvertoad||2017.11.08 - 04:35PM||1: The Incident in the Hallway||Signed |
|Love it already! The start just as I hoped and much promising. How difficult may it be to research the emotions of a person one cares a lot, if you are not able to put in order your own emotions and feelings??? Canīt wait to read on!
Author's Response: I'm happy that you enjoyed the first chapter! Severus will find it much easier to analyse someone else's feelings than his own. Isn't that always the case? I guess the same is true for other people's faults as well :) Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
|Karline||2017.11.08 - 03:03PM||1: The Incident in the Hallway||Signed |
|After reading the original story I was more than happy to see the ending comment about a sequel... and looking into the first chapter now I am sure it will be as wonderful as the other story! What a wonderful start and what a good topic to look into, I am sure there is a wide field of things to explore and I am really looking forward to read more!|
Author's Response: There is always so much more to explore in Ms. Rowling's world, and I'm really grateful that she gave us this huge playground! In a way, this story will be an accumulation of some things I wanted to touch on.. Hopefully, you'll find them interesting, too. Thanks for reading and reviewing!
|loreen77||2017.11.07 - 05:19AM||1: The Incident in the Hallway||Signed |
| What a wonderful start. I am so happy that you were writing a sequel and really look forward to seeing it unfold. Her emotional distress in this first chapter made my heart break.|
Author's Response: Oh - thank you very much! I always admire writers who manage to make you feel the character's pain. I honestly wouldn't pride myself in being able to do that. But then, it's awfully hard to judge one's own writing skills, I guess. So thank you for the compliment - it really makes me happy!
|ilovecake90||2017.11.06 - 10:53AM||1: The Incident in the Hallway||Signed |
|I love it!!! I can't wait to read more. |
Author's Response: I just put up the next chapter. Getting reviews is really an incentive! Thank you!
|Sampdoria||2017.11.06 - 08:11AM||1: The Incident in the Hallway||Signed |
|Thank you for posting the sequel, absolutely brilliantly written. You raise a good point: All the children affected by the war (and yes, Slytherins on the wrong side, or with family on the wrong side is included), why haven't anyone truly talked to them? How could the adults just expect them to fight for their life, and their world, and then go back to being students without any guidance and/or treatment? Again, thank you so much for the chapter and the sequel. |
Author's Response: Well, I guess in the world Ms. Rowling painted for us, children are being treated differently than what we consider normal nowadays. Honestly - had one of my children been a pupil at Hogwarts, I'd have pulled them out right after the troll incident. :) I also wonder why Ginny never got counselling after being possesed by Voldemort through the Diary. She must have had some kind of trauma after that experience, no? The wizarding world seems a bit more cruel and careless about quite a few things (think of what they do with all those poor animals in Transfiguration :o ) Anyway, thanks again for sharing your thoughts on this!!