Reviews for Snape is the Story, Hermione the Reader
| Greengem | 2021.12.20 - 10:29PM | 1: SSHG in Canon | Signed |
| Perfect. |
| Sl_ai | 2020.01.09 - 03:48PM | 1: SSHG in Canon | Signed |
| Great review! Imo Snape knew about stealing from his office: who else could deal with cat hair-Polyjuice Potion's effects rather than the Potions Master? What's a marvellous coincident, isn't it. Also I'm sure that as an adult Hermione would understand the teeth incident. What else could Snape do in front of Death Eater's kids? Defending her would be dangerous for both of them. Careless as he was about his own appearance, obviously he provoked her so Hermione could flea. In the next chapter she was newspapers-famous "stunningly pretty" girl and a top student. Whoa, what a rollercoaster, so much for a public opinion.
For them working together makes more sense than not, even if she knew his secrets. And Dumbledore was a little too obvious talking with Severus: said that Dark Lord will return from the beginning, tried to force conflict between Harry and Voldemort literally for years, mentioned that souls equal minds in their case etc. Brilliant student and inventor as he was, had Severus completely lost his mind not to catch clues? And detention with Hagrid, really? Questions, questions :) |
| DistinctVagueness | 2019.10.21 - 09:05PM | 1: SSHG in Canon | Signed |
| I missed this way back when it was posted, and to my delight, discovered it this evening. It's eerily like a conversation I'd love to be able to have with someone, should I ever meet someone who has an academic fascination with HP as well as a literary love. This is absolutely brilliant. I love your piece-by-piece dissection of their canon relationship. I think if one were to ever try to convince someone to dip their toe into the SS/HG water, this would be a great starting point. A fantastic, well-written, compelling and enjoyable analysis of their connection throughout the books. Loved it. -DV |
| Ive | 2019.07.21 - 11:04AM | 1: SSHG in Canon | Signed |
| Great work! Dare I hope you are a fellow Ravenclaw? We need the house points! |
| Jinxed | 2017.12.17 - 04:58AM | 1: SSHG in Canon | Signed |
| Such a well-written, thoughtful and thought provoking analysis of these two pivotal characters and the roles they play. I really enjoyed reading this piece and feel the need to re-read the books again. Thank you for sharing this. |
| loves23rules | 2017.11.07 - 04:21PM | 1: SSHG in Canon | Signed |
| Excellent text! I really enjoyed your analysis. |
| bccaw | 2015.06.04 - 07:30PM | 1: SSHG in Canon | Signed |
| Wonderful analysis, and a great explanation of why SSHG works and why so many of us read and write this ship - we want to see these like-minded allies together at last. They are the most important and interesting characters in HP canon, in my opinion. |
| smirking_slyth | 2015.05.01 - 07:17PM | 1: SSHG in Canon | Signed |
| This is a great analysis of the books! I'm buzzing after reading it - it's heartwarming so find such convincing evidence for SSHG in canon. Thank you! |
[Previous] 1 2 3 4 [Next]
|