Reviews for Yet Everything Stays the Same
ivylovesnarry | 2015.04.21 - 09:53PM | 17: Was It Worth It? | Signed |
I'm crying but I don't hate you, I promise. This is a brilliant story, well written, with wonderful characters - Hermione & Snape of course but also Harry (that letter!) and Ron. There were a few things that didn't work for me, like Severus not knowing occlumency & legilimency (the dark lord would never have sent him to spy on Dumbledore, he wouldn't have had a chance to be believed) or the way Voldemort treated him (I think he was much more subtle than that, at least at the time, before spending almost 15 years without a body, sinking into greater madness). But it doesn't matter because it was still believable and very clever to twist the time travelling plot this way, and the story is so touching - in a way I think it's even worse for Severus, knowing everything beforehand, living a script, how batshit crazy he must have felt sometimes ! You're right though, in this story the hero needed to die, it's inexorable if heartbreaking, adding so much depth to his actions. So, thank you for writing such a beautiful story, I had a great time reading it and I'm saving it to read again some time ! |
FallFast | 2015.04.02 - 01:03AM | 17: Was It Worth It? | Signed |
Wow... I'm so glad to have stumbled across this story, albeit a little late. My heart skipped a beat thinking it was SS at the door! It's refreshing to read a fic that's brave enough to kill it's darling. Thanks for a great read |
Dimplz | 2014.07.31 - 09:59PM | 17: Was It Worth It? | Signed |
Damn, I was hoping and praying! LOL Oh well. Very good story. Thanks for writing.
Author's Response: thanks for reviewing! |
Buggy | 2014.07.08 - 12:27AM | 17: Was It Worth It? | Signed |
Brilliant! One of the best I've read.
Author's Response: thank you so much! |
page 394 | 2014.06.01 - 10:09PM | 17: Was It Worth It? | Signed |
Thank God for the random fic button.... this is one of the best stories I've read.
Author's Response: thanks! i love your screenname! :) |
lunarose | 2014.03.18 - 12:32AM | 17: Was It Worth It? | Signed |
I just had to leave a review to remind you how wonderful a story this is. I've just finished reading it for a second time having stumbled across it again and it's just as brilliant as the first time. My heart aches with the beauty of it as I cry over so many lost possibilities for Severus and Hermione. And yet, the way it ended, is exactly how it needed to because as you have Snape say the hero never lives. Simply brilliant.
Author's Response: thank you so much for such a lovely review! |
marisamarinee | 2014.01.08 - 06:20PM | 17: Was It Worth It? | Signed |
Cried so hard, knowing that they weren't going to end up tougher. But it's understandable. I enjoyed it. Lol now I need some hardcore fluff
Author's Response: thanks for taking the time to review! |
marisamarinee | 2014.01.08 - 05:45PM | 15: And In the End | Signed |
:( I wish he survived
Author's Response: i don't. |
[Previous] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 [Next]
|