Reviews for Fruit Of A Bitter Harvest
|Mikimoto||2018.07.08 - 10:50PM||9: Final chapter||Signed |
|Lovely story. I think they stay married. Why? Because Hermione is no fool. She has the Arithmancy chair and would need to be at Hogwarts. How could she do that with another husband and Severus watching? She is not that cruel.|
|Ljpjcg||2017.12.12 - 04:49PM||9: Final chapter||Signed |
|I think this ending is absolutely perfect even when there's so much ambiguity towards the outcome. I hope Severus' depth of feeling is reciprocated and a true loving partnership will develop. |
|OfSpock||2017.04.03 - 08:21PM||9: Final chapter||Signed |
|Truly beautiful. |
Author's Response: Hi OfSpock, very many thanks for the lovely review.
|Helena Rickman||2015.07.26 - 12:10PM||9: Final chapter||Signed |
|The ending? Well, I know how this ends. Hermione loves him, and knows he will approach this the most self - depricating way possible. Of course she rips the annulment up.
Thanks for a very loving and well written story. Helena|
Author's Response: And thank you for taking the time to review and who knows perhaps I will at last get around to the sequel.
|fallconsmate||2015.02.15 - 11:00PM||9: Final chapter||Signed |
|i can understand why people would wish rotten tomatoes upon you for this unsure ending...but i think it is better for NOT having a happy ending. the whole story is laid on a bedrock of unhappy begining and then slowly building towards friendship and understanding. we do not need to know how it ends, THEY know how it ends. it ends, as it should have begun, with *choice*. and that's the best thing severus could give to hermione, choice where she had none.|
Author's Response: Hi I was pleasantly surprised to get very few tomatoes. The end and beginning were written in about 20 mins, and though tempted it just did not feel right to alter the end. I am glad you enjoyed it and took the time to review.
|duj||2014.09.14 - 12:55PM||9: Final chapter||Signed |
|I think this story is stronger with this ending. The rest of their story could go in a sequel. It doesn't belong here.|
Author's Response: Hi duj,
thanks for the vote for the ending being as was, I agree the rest is suited for a sequel.
|asprickman||2012.11.27 - 09:05PM||9: Final chapter||Signed |
|This is getting worrying - 2 a.m and I just had to re-read the whole 9 chapters. told you - your writing is addictive! This is masterly, a superb piece of writing; different in style from many of your other stories which is impressive, equally well crafted and written but a very different `feel'. I think you were quite right to stick with your original ending, much as I would adore a sequel. It works brilliantly leaving it open, allows me to be certain they stay together - the respect, mutual consideration and friendship is so strong. Having said that I do hope you complete and publish the continuation of this tale, I'd love to know what you decide for them and, more importantly, I'd love to read it as I just adore your creativity, perfect characterisations, ability to really get into, and explain, the minds of your characters and your use of language - yep, you guessed it, I'm a fan!|
Author's Response: Hi asprickman, You know the true joy of any writer is in the reviews they receive. Sometimes they stimulate discussion or thought, sometimes they bring a smile, sometimes they warm your heart. Yours, cariad, do all three, or is that four. though I am feeling guilty of depriving you of sleep. I agree that this one is different in style and feel to the others it was the most stubborn one. The beginning and the end appeared almost as they appear in the final draft in the space of about twenty minutes, the rest went through about three different versions and sat about glaring at me from the hard drive for the better part of a year. As for the continuation, I thought I had the idea planned out and then it started behaving like its predecessor. It is still being worked on (very slowly) but I never post unless I feel that a story has legs and is complete. In addition an original story has been bugging me to write it for a while now. Now I just have to get the time. Thank you for your enthusiasm and for the joy your reviews have brought. Perhaps if I get the speech recognition software it will up my rather slow writing speed. Thank you once again.:) shuldham
|Buggy||2012.10.12 - 09:16PM||9: Final chapter||Signed |
|utterly sublime, thank you!|
Author's Response: Many, many thanks, Buggy x
[Previous] 1 2 3 4 5 [Next]