Reviews for She's the One
duj | 2022.02.24 - 08:13AM | 1: She's the One | Signed |
Good choice. Lily might be calling him, but does she actually want him or is she just trying to make sure he stays dead? (Is it actually her? Maybe it's a Polyjuiced James wanting to bully him again for the fact that he exists...) |
dragonsbanehidren | 2011.12.07 - 03:00AM | 1: She's the One | Signed |
Every time I read this snippet--and I do so often--I get chills. Very striking. |
Overhill | 2010.08.20 - 02:31AM | 1: She's the One | Signed |
I like the idea that Severus got to chose between the two women. Good reason for him to return to the living. Lily will always be there on the other side of death, but for now.... |
Jong_Kahn | 2010.08.11 - 12:30AM | 1: She's the One | Signed |
All the previous reviewers were right. Still, it is a short little vignette. At least he went back to Hermione! Nicely done. |
verasuspense | 2010.08.10 - 09:51AM | 1: She's the One | Signed |
Lily never needed him - Hermione does. |
WnL624 | 2010.08.07 - 01:21PM | 1: She's the One | Signed |
Poignantly beautiful, thank you. |
MlleGigi | 2010.08.07 - 12:06PM | 1: She's the One | Signed |
Maybe it's just me...but I find this story a little depressing. Perhaps this is because I'm feeling a little depressed already right now...but it seems as if Severus turns back because he sees Hermione as a duty and doesn't want to hurt her. There's no question that he cares for Hermione -- he wouldn't have turned back if she didn't matter to him -- but I get the sense that Lily is the one whom he really loves and not Hermione. |
[Previous] 1 2 [Next]
|