Reviews for And The Stars Never Rise
loreen77 | 2016.03.12 - 09:48AM | 1: And The Stars Never Rise | Signed |
Heartbreakingly sad, beautiful and poignant. You conveyed the emotionally raw gut wrenching depth of his love and loss so beautifully. I wept like a child as I read this. Thanks you for sharing and I am sorry for whatever loss you personally have experienced that allowed you to convey this so realistically. |
EmpressNan | 2014.06.19 - 11:57PM | 1: And The Stars Never Rise | Signed |
As someone who has lost a spouse to cancer, I have to say you nailed this perfectly. The debilitating grief, the blinding anger, and even the submergence into memories in a ritualized fashion. Raw and real. Sad and sweet. And utterly beautiful. Well done. |
gottawrite | 2013.03.23 - 10:32AM | 1: And The Stars Never Rise | Signed |
In all the years I have been on Ashwinder, I am not sure I have ever read this piece until today. If I had to choose one word to describe the heart-shattering sadness that was created from your words I couldn't. I want to reach into the story and give Snape a hug because his wallowing and bitterness isn't what Hermione would have wanted. But alas, words on the paper can only take us so far. Well done, beautifully written.
Author's Response: Thank you so much for your lovely feedback. I realize this story can be rather painful, so I appreciate the fact you read it all the more. And I absolutely agree with you -- Hermione would not have wanted that for him. :-( |
Ljpjcg | 2011.12.31 - 02:55PM | 1: And The Stars Never Rise | Signed |
*sob*
Heart is broken. Very beautiful. His grief is overwhelming, losing two loves in his short lifetime.
Author's Response: Thank you so much for reading and for willing to let your heart be broken for our beloved hero. I really appreciate it - not many folks are willing to read tragedy, so I'm quite grateful to receive a review for this story. Thank you!! |
snowy_owl | 2010.05.17 - 08:22AM | 1: And The Stars Never Rise | Signed |
I'm not sure I've ever had a one-chapter fic send me into floods of tears like this. Achingly beautiful, heart wrenching. Thank you.
Author's Response: I'm glad you took the chance on this story (with its many warnings) and decided to read it. It's actually my most favorite piece of fan-fiction I've written. Not that I've written all that much. :-) Thanks so much for the review and your kind words. |
Black Aliss | 2009.10.02 - 11:45PM | 1: And The Stars Never Rise | Signed |
This is so very heart-wrenching..but she gave Severus a taste of love and that should be something to him. Many don't get that experience (love) in a lifetime. Your story is excellent. Thank you.
Author's Response: Yes, that's certainly true. Thank you so much for reading the story and leaving a review. I really appreciate it! |
FireBlade | 2009.07.26 - 03:53PM | 1: And The Stars Never Rise | Signed |
This was very bittersweet. You did an amazing job with this story, I like your writing style.
Author's Response: Thank you so much! It was quite different than what I prefer to write, but it was also one of those ideas that gripped me and would not let go. Thanks for reading it, and thanks for leaving a review! |
poopotter | 2009.06.22 - 06:52AM | 1: And The Stars Never Rise | Signed |
u know what..this is one of the best angst fic i hav ever read!....really a great one!...thanx for writing this....u really touched my heart with ur word!....
Author's Response: Thank you so much for your lovely praise. I don't generally write such tragic stories, but this one wouldn't let me go. I appreciate the feedback! |
[Previous] 1 2 3 4 5 [Next]
|