Reviews for Love Songs
get_sirius | 2005.12.07 - 05:54PM | 1: Collide, Love Song I | Signed |
that was SO good!
awwwwwwww. i luff it!!!
Harry and Ron =perfect!
YAAAAAAAY.
Author's Response: hahaha thank you! |
droxy | 2005.12.06 - 10:10PM | 1: Collide, Love Song I | Signed |
angsty with a romatic ending- nice short fic.
Author's Response: Thank you, I'm glad you liked it! |
flourishandblotts | 2005.12.06 - 05:20PM | 1: Collide, Love Song I | Anonymous |
Very sweet. A wonderful happy ending!
Author's Response: Haha thank you! I love happy endings too! |
Potions Mistresss | 2005.12.06 - 04:11PM | 1: Collide, Love Song I | Signed |
Ooh, I like it!! Lovely. Maybe you'll write more? I hope so, that was great.
Author's Response: Thank you! I have a bunch of ideas but haven't sorted them out yet. |
kateluvya | 2005.12.06 - 01:42PM | 1: Collide, Love Song I | Signed |
'Kay. I've never been a big fan of song fics (because I never know the songs), but this one was awesome! I liked how you kept the song verses short (that way I didn't have to wade through a whole song to find the connections), and I liked how the song really did connect to the piece. It's very well written (and beta'd), the plot flows smoothly and has an awesome climax. Awesome fic!
Author's Response: Thank you - I'm glad you liked the story. And the wonderful beta-ing goes to Rhiannon :) |
JumboShrimp | 2005.12.06 - 12:02PM | 1: Collide, Love Song I | Signed |
Hey, it's Rhiannon. I just wanted to say great job! Congratulations on getting it accepted here at Ashwinder. Keep up the good work and let me know if you need me again. |
JumboShrimp | 2005.12.06 - 11:54AM | 1: Collide, Love Song I | Signed |
Hey, it's Rhiannon. I just wanted to say great job! Congratulations on getting it accepted here at Ashwinder. Keep up the good work and let me know if you need me again.
Author's Response: :) Thank you Rhiannon! Without your help, I couldn't have had it come out this way! |
WickedlyWanton | 2005.12.06 - 08:31AM | 1: Collide, Love Song I | Signed |
Well, I don't know if I liked this or not. As far as a love story, it's not bad. I was a little confused on the flashback at first and the way it transitions; you don't really have any. It goes from the battle, to the flashback, to the aftermath. I don't even really see the song matching. However, I think that could be just me not really getting song fics ;). I did like it as far as it was fluff, but if you wanted something of substance, think about adding some more to it. The bare bones explanations could be expanded-I think you could have done a multi chapter fic with each verse of the song and come out wonderfully.
Author's Response: Thank you for reviewing - I was going to spin it out longer but I'm always afraid of doing chaptered stories in case I suddenly get stuck in the middle :). But I think I'll use that idea for another song that will work better in a prolonged fic. Thank you! |
|